"These are the high-flying cranes (al-gharāniq), whose intercession is to be hoped for."
The translation on page 111 proceeds to detail the subsequent correction:
The text you're looking for from The History of al-Tabari, Volume 6, Page 111
The journey through Volume 6, Page 111 of al-Tabari’s History is a powerful lesson in the importance of context, methodology, and intellectual honesty. Taking the quote at face value is a fundamental error, as it ignores al-Tabari's historiographical method and the verdict of the vast majority of Islamic scholarship.
I should offer to help them locate the text if they can provide more details, like the exact topic discussed on page 111, or suggest scholarly articles and books that reference that volume. Maybe recommend works like "Al-Tabari's Tarikh" by Fred Donner or other critical studies. Also, suggest they check academic databases for papers that cite al-Tabari, Volume 6. al tabari volume 6 page 111
The verses in question, often referred to as the "Satanic Verses," were consequently abrogated (removed) from the Quranic text, following this intervention. Significance and Analysis of the Episode
Volume 6 of al-Tabari's history covers a pivotal period in Islamic history. Without the specific details on page 111, one can infer that this section likely discusses significant events, personalities, or theological debates characteristic of the era. Al-Tabari's method of presenting multiple accounts of events allows readers to engage with diverse viewpoints and traditions.
: Search for keywords like “al-Tabari Year 10 Hijri” or “al-Tabari Vol. 6 Chapter X” in academic databases to find studies referencing this material.
If page 111 discusses the Hadith of the Night Journey (Isra) : Maybe recommend works like "Al-Tabari's Tarikh" by Fred
The detailed accounts provided by al-Tabari, such as those found on , have had a lasting impact on Islamic historiography. His work serves as a fundamental reference for scholars and historians, offering a rich source of information on early Islamic history. Moreover, al-Tabari's balanced approach to recording events, which includes diverse perspectives and rationales behind significant decisions, has been a model for subsequent historians.
The narratives also shed light on the social and cultural practices of the time, offering contemporary readers a glimpse into the world of early Islam.
serves as a focal point in academic historiography, polemics, and Islamic studies. This specific page falls within the text titled Muhammad at Mecca , translated and annotated by W. Montgomery Watt and M.V. McDonald. This text covers the early prophetic mission of Muhammad. Academically and polemically, this page contains discussions regarding the historical narration known as the "Satanic Verses" or the Incident of the Cranes ( Qissat al-Gharaniq ) . The Context of Volume 6
: Al-Tabari explicitly notes in his introduction that his goal was to compile historical accounts, not to verify the theological orthodoxy of every narration. Understanding the Narrative on Page 111 Significance and Analysis of the Episode Volume 6
The tradition reports that Gabriel subsequently informs Muhammad that Satan had cast these words onto his tongue during a moment of desire to reconcile with his people.
On this page, Al-Tabari records a narration detailing a moment when the Prophet Muhammad was deeply eager to find a reconciliation with his tribe, the Quraysh, who had rejected his monotheistic message. According to the narrative found on :
: